SCOTUSblog's list of petitions with a "reasonable" chance of being granted
    
 Conference of 4/13

Click the highlighted docket number to download the cert. petition - other documents linked to as available.

Name
Counsel of Record
Certiorari To
DN
Summary of QP
Status
Oklahoma v. Coddington
Seth Branham
OK AG's office
OK Ct. of Crim. App.
06-889
Whether the lower court's interpretation of Lockett v. Ohio violates this Court's holding in Johnson v. Texas that a jury need only "be able to consider in some manner all of a defendant's relevant mitigating evidence," and need not "be able to give effect to mitigating evidence in every conceivable manner in which the evidence might be relevant."

Yusuf v. US
Leon Friedman
New York, NY
CA3
06-892
Whether the Third Circuit erred in approving a search where the search warrant affidavit was not attached to the warrant and the warrant permitted a search for evidence of all "illegal activities" and all "illegal business activities," without limitations or particularity. (Petition coming soon)

Fishing Vessel Choloe Z v. Matos
David Frederick
KHHTEF
CA9
06-899
Whether the three-year statute of limitations for maritime tort actions bars a suit filed more than three years after the claim arose, when the plaintiff filed a prior, timely suit asserting the same claim but failed to pursue the claim in that prior suit.  (Also available: BIO, Reply, Int'l Group Amicus)

County Bank of Rehoboth Beach v. Muhammad
Claudia Callaway
Manatt, Phelps & Phillips
S. Ct. of NJ
06-907
Whether a class arbitration waiver in an otherwise enforceable arbitration agreement is unenforceable and must be stricken.  (Also available: BIO, Reply)
MetLife v. Glenn
Lee Paterson
Winston & Strawn
CA6
06-923
Whether the Sixth Circuit erred in holding that the fact that a claim administrator of an ERISA plan also funds the plan benefits constitutes a "conflict of interest" which must be weighed in a judicial review of the administrator's benefit determination under Firestone Tire & Rubber v. Bruch.  (Petition coming soon)
Daewoo v. General Motors
Larry Robbins
Robbins Russell
CA11
06-926
Whether a district court's dismissal of a lawsuit, under the doctrine of international comity and based on the preclusive effect of a foreign judgment, is reviewable de novo or only for abuse of discretion.  (Also available: BIO of Suzuki, Bio of GM, Reply)
Quanta Computer v. LG
Maureen Mahoney
Latham & Watkins
CA Fed
06-937
Whether the Federal Circuit erred by holding that respondent's patent rights were not exhausted by its license agreement with Intel Corporation, and Intel's subsequent sale of product under the license to petitioners.  (Also available: BIO, Reply)
Chamber of Commerce v. Lockyer

                                                                                                                                                                                                  
Willis Goldsmith
Jones Day
                                       
CA9
06-939

Whether California's regulation of noncoercive employer speech about union organizing, California Assembly Bill 1889, Cal. Gov't Code secs. 16645.2, 16645.7, is preempted by federal labor law.  (Also available: BIO, Reply)


Arthur v. Allen Suhana Han
Sullivan & Cromwell
CA11
06-954

Whether the courts below erred in denying a petitioner sentenced to death an opportunity to develop a gateway claim of actual innocence through which he seeks collateral review of his first federal habeas petition that has never been reviewed on the merits.  (Also available: BIO, Reply)


Jordan v. Alternative Resources Corp.                                                                                                               Stephen Chertkof
Heller, Huron
CA4
06-1086

Whether, where an employee promptly complains about an incident of harassment, the employer can lawfully retaliate for that complaint until the point that there were so many other incidents of harassment that the employee could reasonably conclude that an unlawful hostile work environment has been created.  (Also available: BIO, NELA Amicus)


Media Six v. Ziglar
Conrad M. Shumadine
Willcox & Savage                  

S. Ct. of VA
06-1127
Whether a letter to the editor of a newspaper must be thoroughly investigated to determine whether the statements are true else the newspaper will be found liable.  (Petition coming soon)

Doe v. Kamehameha Schools
Eric Grant
Sacramento, CA
CA9
06-1202
Whether respondent private schools' racially exclusionary admissions policy is subject to the same strict scrutiny applied under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, or instead is subject to the marginally less demanding scrutiny applied under Title VII of that Act.  (Also available: BIO, Reply)